Its not like she was secretly happy for him not being there so that she meet with Guy. If Claireignored her pride and asked Phil for help to begin with, Phil would have had more confidence. This actually causes quite a lot of issues in Modern Family. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. She didn't even want to marry him after she found out she was pregnant. Many of the jokes are strained, the premises contrived or repetitious. When she's not writing, Aya enjoys working out, reading a good book (usually a thriller) with a cup of coffee, and spending time with friends and family. Determining someone's 'type' could be tricky and even impossible, but Phil and Claire both clearly have a type. Neither did she ask Jay to make an effort to make Phil better about himself and nor did she talk to Phil about not outdoing herself just to impress Jay. But there are so many things about their relationship that simply dont add up. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Phil shared that he and the husband made a bet so Phil had to keep paying, and Claire was mad. The focus simply shifted to Claires workplace and how she balanced her home and her profession, but since their kids were grown up now, wouldnt it make more sense for Claire to suggest that Phil take more charge around the house? She would've dumped him already. But in Claire's one-track mind, she was sick of the ducks and tried to get rid of them when Phil was out of the house. In fact, he does his best to ensure that Claire and Laura (his client) never meet. The famous 'good cop bad cop' approach to parenting or rather the 'good cop/mom' approach to parenting is usually how things go in the Dunphy household. While Phil and Claire are great parents, they did see things differently, and their parentingapproachescaused some conflict as Claire would get worked up and Phil would be chill about the given situation. Its a nice little play on the typical affair storyline, and it even ends with a little heart, with Phil silently acknowledging that yeah, this whole parenting and working thing is damn hard. In the season1 episode "Hawaii," the family went on a fun vacation, and Phil had a surprise up his sleeve. whenever they have lovey dovey scenes i always wonder when they started to actually love each other because its repeated several times that had it not been for haley they never wouldve lasted past six months. She called Phil's dad to invite Phil down to Florida for a couple of days while Claire had the whole house to herself. does phil cheat on claire in modern family. Now thats doing your business in luxury. Whereas Claire was a superbly popular teenager who's used to dating jocks when she met the nerdy Phil. and our RELATED:Modern Family: 10 Things That Make No Sense About Haley & Dylan's Relationship. He never fixed the step on the staircase. When it was time for Haley to think about higher education, he took her on a tour of his school, even showing her the cafeteria trays that he used to slide down. Claire is more aggressive than Phil in a lot of ways so it's easy to list all the ways she's wronged him, but Phil has made some mistakes as well. Skip to content. Now, not every single B-plot has to have its own unique flavor, but Modern Family is certainly at its best when its comedic subplots are grounded in character work from previous seasons and episodes. He fawned over Gloria in front of Clair. edgewater hotel haunted; can uk consultant doctors work in usa; is spitfire a compliment This couple got married hastily after Claire got pregnant with Haley. Phil still liked his father-in-law. When he felt Claire is upset about Denise he invited her home. Phil Dunphy says the last line in 'Modern Family' At the beginning of season 11, it seemed like the Dunphy clan would never leave their house. Not knowing she had additional help (yet), it made Phil feel belittled and not good enough as a father. Like how they each approach parenting, and how they lie to each other for small insignificant reasons when they both want an honest relationship. One example was in the fifth season episode "iSpy" when they thought that Luke was doing drugs. ThisModern Familycouple had their differences but they were phenomenal parents who supported each other. Gloria slowly makes her way outside to get Joe from the car, Jay gets rid of the bowl of Glorias food, and Manny and Luke sneak away with the laptop. Also yes, sometimes she wants to feel still young and attractive. While Phil and Claire's parenting dynamic represents a traditional style of parenting. Their love for their children made it work. Phil and Claire always supported the career dreams and goals that they each had. 'Modern Family' Season 11 airs every Wednesday at 9/8c only on ABC. Still, there are some questionable things about their relationship. Phil and Claire eloped (and finally had a real wedding on one episode of 'Modern Family') This couple got married hastily after Claire got pregnant with Haley. Meanwhile, Jay (Ed ONeill) and Gloria (Sofia Vergara) will also have a misunderstanding in the episode. While Claire always wanted to be in chargeand that can be seen as a negative quality, she always meant well as she loved her kids and thought she did the right thing. 100% she wouldnt have cheated on Phil. So no. They both wanted to cheat in multiple episodes monogamous relationships had have cheating most are just too blind to see. They generally enjoys each others company. Cookie Notice Lynn is a nomad who travels the globe on the hunt for her next adventure with her husband. For a couple that's been married for so long, it's weird how they didn't acknowledge each other's need for some me-time. Who cares? I thought that it started this way, as yk, Claire got pregnant, they didnt have a wedding, Jay wasnt making it any easy either. First, there was barely any indication that Lily was at the wedding with them, making her later inclusion feel quite jarring. Phil even makes jokes about Claire being a marketing major at a party school, but the fact that Claire had a life before Phil somewhat hurts him. They didn't know what they were doing, but they figured it out together, and this bonded them more than anything ever could. While total opposites, Phil and Claire Dunphy are one of the most compelling married couples on Modern Family. So no. Claire didn't say much about this purchase which annoyed Phil even more because she knew it wasn't going to last. Yes, it's Ben Affleck! For more information, please see our It's telling that when Haley fell in love, Phil was the one who supported her and got to know her boyfriends, not Claire. Besides, Claire was bummed when she thought Phil couldnt make it to Paris for Valentines Day. She lives in Toronto with her husband and has a special interest in teen dramas, reality TV, and horror movies. He fell for her the 1st time he saw her & didn't want to lose the chance. While Phil had a soft spot for Luke and the two were similar in many ways, he definitely loved all his children equally. Rather than creating comedy built outward from the characters, the premises and punchlines seem to come first, and then put into the mouths of characters after the fact. Is it just me or are the Luke and Manny pair-ups always disappointing? Modern Family: 5 Worst Things Claire Did To Phil (& 5 Phil Did To Claire), Modern Family: The Worst Thing Each Main Character Has Done, Modern Family: 10 Fictional Families Who Are More Dysfunctional Than The Dunphys, Modern Family: The 10 Best Halloween Costumes On The Show, Modern Family: 10 Times Phil Embarrassed His Kids, Ranked, Modern Family: Funniest Halloween Episodes, Ranked, It's True, Matt Smith's Post-Doctor Who Success Breaks A 60-Year Trend, The Last Of Us Episode 6 Was A Stealth Reunion For Beloved 90s Sitcom, 6 Possibilities For Who Entered The Room In Criminal Minds' Finale. She has a Political Science and Media Studies degree from the University of Toronto and a Masters of Journalism from Ryerson University. Lately though, the show has just been churning out blas storylines that cant even feign depth or any interest in making sure that, seven seasons in, the show is still moving its characters to new and interesting places. While Claire and Phil hide out in their bedroom, the kids leave the house and talk about what happened over ice cream, with Luke noting that he would rather have parents who do that than parents who are divorced like many of his friends; they make a deal to sit poker-faced through Claire's subsequent address to them, which makes Claire happy does phil cheat on claire in modern family. In my mind,because of her terrible relationship with her own mother, she wanted to be a better mother to her children. And he would never have done that to Jay either. In S2 valentine's day they made fun of Alex(though she was right). However, now as empty-nesters for the first time in 25 years,. Was Alex Dunphy the Valedictorian of Her High School? As a realtor and a parent to three kids, Phil would have to find out his mistake on his own, but it was pretty uncool of him to impulsively buy something so expensive. You got downvoted cuz you seem to come looking for a pathetic excuse to defend on Clair (Phil has always been goofy as hell, since she met him). I didn't see the relationship as forced or trapped at any point. In one last family trip, they head to Paris so Jay can accept a lifetime achievement award in the closet industry, but his old nemesis comes back to haunt him. Here are the worst things the Dunphy couples has done to each other. Privacy Policy. The first time Bixby introduces. We know Phil loves Claire, but does he have some doubts? Her boyfriend, Rainer Shine (Nathan Fillion), is unable to go out on a date with her. Also, could you not just sub in Phil and Claire for Cam and Mitchell and have the exact same sequence of events take place? I dont know if Im the only one who finds this very inconsiderate of Phil, even if it is presented as a lasting joke in the show. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Wont the drama also be quite played out if they did the same thing every year? Phil is not exactly a predator or even consciously unfaithful, as hes by all means fairly devoted. Thats what matters. In an effort to have Phil think Juliana is repulsive, it starts to work but throws Phil off. Modern Family is going through a serious rough patch this season. Mitchell will be there but he might also not like that Claire dumped Phil as Phil might be among few of her boyfriends who was nice to him. But he was dating denise then & had trouble breaking bad news he couldn't break up with denise instantly. Every single scene of them together just gives me butterflies. If her family(Dede) was supportive, she might not even move in with him. He was break-dancing at the time and was possibly looking quite awkward and it's really unlikely that they got together as instantaneously as they'd led people to believe. To fill the void, Phil found a nest of duck eggs and decided to raise them until they were old enough to soar. But since all they do is meet at a hotel bar and have sex with each other, wouldn't they rather be trying new things each time? The boyfriend in Paris thing was not only a coincidence, but she hung out with him, WITH Phil. Modern Family S11E13 'Paris' Episode discussion thread. Heres what we know about ABCs comedy series. To be fair, he needed a car anyway; he was just supposed to get a more family-friendly vehicle not a convertible with little room. Press J to jump to the feed. Claire Dunphy may be a bit of a control-freak and Phil Dunphy may be pretty happy-go-lucky, but these two make a perfect couple. It took her six months or more( the way she said it "six months?!) Its obvious that Jay never really grew fond of Phil. You would think it would be the opposite. What do you mean, they barely tolerated each other from the start? By the looks of it, Phils plans will do their marriage good. One home, in particular, called the Sexy House, had everyone under a trance. When Claire told Phil, he brushed it off and said it was totally fine. The episode was written by Joe Lawson and directed by Jason Winer.. It seems that Rainers excuse of needing to go to the weather station is not true. Claire and Phil often lie to each other for insignificant reasons, like when Claire lied to Phil about going to Lukes soccer match without him. Lots of couples do break up in this situation. AmazonKOMONE (2,) . While Phil was happy-go-lucky and loved seeing the good in people, he needed to be more observant sometimes. Also, the paris episode. A place for fans of ABC's hit show Modern Family. Instead of making their house scary, he decided to make it awesome and fun. Little did he know that Claire actually had. What that means is that so many of the storylines from week to week feel interchangeable, as if a character from one subplot could be subbed into another subplot and nobody would even notice. RELATED:Modern Family: The 5 Most Annoying Things Cameron Ever Did (And 5 Sweetest). I agree with the other poster that, due to characterizations being thrown out the window, that we don't know what this episode's Claire would have done and that it doesn't matter at this point. They always made time for each other, no matter how busy they were. While Modern Family's Claire and Phil Dunphy may be polar opposites, this married sitcom couple truly loves each other and are great parents together. And since dense is very in keeping with Phils character and not afraid to risk temptation kind of fits Clair, what to take at face value is muddied. Theres no spark anymore, no charm, and even the sharp comedic timing has lacked as of late. FOLLOW MORE IBT NEWS ON THE BELOW CHANNELS, IBT Fast Start - Let the best of International News come to you. But after a wager with the neighbors gets in Claire's head, she decides to eliminate AwesomeLand when Phil leaves the house. Maybe why stuff with Gloria & other women didn't bother her. She was wild and would most likely have continued that way but then she got pregnant and in those difficult moments, Phil stepped up. When Phil challenges Claire to a run, he tries to . The entire family was trying to find their way inside this house for a night of passion. RELATED:Modern Family: Cam's Most Memorable Fizbo Moments, Ranked. The series is not realistic and consistent enough to insert a dark twist like that. RELATED:Modern Family: 5 Ways The Pritchetts Are Exactly Alike (& 5 Ways They're Different). Modern Family is an American TV comedy series revolving around three families interrelated through Jay Pritchett, his son Mitchell Pritchett, and his daughter Claire Dunphy. The storyline of Phil and Claire's relationship before the show is a bit convoluted and probably has the least continuity. Id argue that you could. I Dont Know How She Does It has a bit more success with its other storylines. Modern Family: 5 Times Claire And Phil's Relationship Was Toxic (& 5 It Was Perfect), Modern Family: Why Alex Is Actually The Show's Main Character, Modern Family: 5 Sitcom Tropes It Uses (& 5 It Avoids), Modern Family: Cam's Most Memorable Fizbo Moments, Ranked, Modern Family: 5 Ways The Pritchetts Are Exactly Alike (& 5 Ways They're Different), Claire and Phil sometimes hurt each other, Modern Family: Mitch & Haley's 10 Best Friendship Moments, Ranked.